Home-based detention will only work if properly supported

“While there are some very positive aspects to home-based detention for some people, I suspect that the key reason for moving toward this policy is not an attempt to reduce the social and economic impacts of increased rates of imprisonment, but simply that our gaols are full,” said Sylvia Hale, Greens MP and spokesperson for Corrective Services.

“Simply keeping people at home does not address the factors that caused them to commit crimes in the first place.

“Many prisoners, of course, end up in gaol as a result of homelessness, unemployment and mental health issues. Of what use will this policy be to them?

“Home-based detention may not be appropriate for all those now eligible to be considered for this form of punishment. If not well supported, it may further entrench disadvantage in our society.

“For it to work, home-detainees must be guaranteed access to literacy, numeracy and skills courses and appropriate support from parole officers or social workers. 

 “Home-based detention, as with weekend detention, is only ever an option for those whom a judge assesses to be at a very low risk of re-offending. It is often suitable for first offenders who would be best kept out of prison and removed from contact with more hardened and experienced inmates.

“Answers I received to questions asked in parliament on 11 March indicate that one of the key reasons for moving away from weekend detention has been the reduction in available beds. It’s equally clear that there has been a long-term winding back of weekend detention.

“The current Government strategy of being seen to be ‘tough on crime’ is costing NSW dearly. This week’s budget papers allocate $966.3 million to custodial services for 2010-2011, an increase of 3.1% on last year’s budget. This includes 250 new beds at Cessnock Gaol and a new 600-bed gaol at Nowra.

“While the budget papers refer to programs to deter criminal behaviour and reduce recidivism, very little money is allocated to these programs, with almost nothing directed towards deterring young people at risk from becoming involved in crime.

Contact: Colin Hesse on 02 9230 3030 or 0401 719 124